Julianna Yau’s blog

Because I need to feed the geek in me.

 

The “Matthew Barney” Model

Gleb Sidorkin has written for Tisch Film Review the article I’ve been wanting to write on this blog about Matthew Barney’s model for generating income from film. Unlike most “indie” film-makers (I use the term loosely — Barney is more of a multimedia artist than a “traditional indie film-maker”), Barney does not seek mass distribution of his work. In fact, most people are probably out of luck if they have missed The Cremaster Cycle or Drawing Restraint while they were “on tour”. It wasn’t until last summer when Anthology Film Archives in New York was screening Cremaster 2 as part of a Norman Mailer event that I was no longer one of the many Barney fans who had not actually seen any of his work. Sidorkin’s article is very thorough and insightful, and provides part of the answer to my burning question: what about visual artists?

Tags: , , , ,

Related posts

Filed under : art, copyright, movies
By Julianna Yau
On March 12, 2008
At 5:52 am
Comments : 0
Print This Post Print This Post

 
 
 

C-10 - Missing the point?

Michael Geist points to an article in The Star by Peter Howell which quotes a spokesperson for Heritage Minister Josée Verner as indicating that “Canadian Heritage has not received an application for a production containing criminal content”.

This is great news, but doesn’t make people’s concerns a simple case of “legal absurdity”. The proposed wording in C-10 uses the phrase “public policy“, and does not speak specifically to issues of criminal content. Again, the concern is not the isolated inclusion of the phrase “public policy”, but its existence alongside Charles McVety’s lobbying “to deny tax credits to TV and film productions that contain graphic sex and violence or other offensive content”.

Tags: , , , , ,

Related posts

Filed under : arts administration, movies
By Julianna Yau
On March 11, 2008
At 7:50 pm
Comments : 0
Print This Post Print This Post

 
 
 

C-10 Opposition Still Going Strong

Filed under : arts administration, movies
By Julianna Yau
On March 8, 2008
At 12:44 pm
Comments : 0
Print This Post Print This Post

 
 
 

Continuing C-10 Drama

Filed under : arts administration, movies
By Julianna Yau
On March 7, 2008
At 6:51 am
Comments : 0
Print This Post Print This Post

 
 
 

Digging deeper into C-10

Filed under : arts administration, movies
By Julianna Yau
On March 5, 2008
At 8:31 pm
Comments : 0
Print This Post Print This Post

 
 
 

Still more responses to C-10

Filed under : arts administration, movies
By Julianna Yau
On
At 6:43 am
Comments : 0
Print This Post Print This Post

 
 
 

More on C-10

A few more chime in on C-10:

Tags: , , , , ,

Related posts

Filed under : arts administration, movies
By Julianna Yau
On March 3, 2008
At 7:19 pm
Comments :1
Print This Post Print This Post

 
 
 

Charles McVety Misses the 1950s, Supports C-10

The internet has been raging with bill C-10, which seems to have become the new media baby now that the government is dragging its feet with releasing the proposed copyright legislation.

Geist is surprisingly brief on his coverage of the activity, with a mere mention and pointing people to one of the anti-C-10 Facebook groups.

The Canadian Conference of the Arts issued a press release on the matter (I’m linking to my own blog because I can’t find it on their website), as did ACTRA and the Directors Guild of Canada.

Trying to read through the entire bill is a nightmare, and I’m grateful to “FF Canuck” for finding the relevant text in the bill. The offending text, in short, is that “public financial support of the production [of a Canadian film or video] would not be contrary to public policy”.

While I agree with some criticisms that this isn’t necessarily or specifically a censorship clause, anyone who reads between the lines (or any of the articles covering the issue) knows its intent is to facilitate censorship. It’s chillingly familiar to the undertones of the House Committee on Un-American Activities, and it’s no wonder everyone is aghast.

Just what exactly is “contrary to public policy”? What exactly is “public policy”? Who decides what “public policy” is and whether a work is contrary to it?

Surely the Canadian government shouldn’t be allowing hateful propaganda, but where do we draw the line…and, more importantly, from where do we draw the line? As others have noted, other provisions are in place to ensure that works which violate human rights are not allowed to be distributed. Is it really the place of the governmental branch in charge of tax credits to determine whether a film should be funded?

Tags: , , , , , ,

Related posts

Filed under : arts administration, movies
By Julianna Yau
On March 2, 2008
At 3:47 pm
Comments : 0
Print This Post Print This Post

 
 
 

CCA Asks: Why Are More Regulations Necessary for Publicly Funded Film and Television Productions?

Ottawa, February 29, 2008 - The National Director of the Canadian Conference of the Arts (CCA), Alain Pineau, has issued a statement today asking why further regulations for the content of publicly funded films and television productions are necessary.

Mr. Pineau notes that the debate for now should be focused on the adequacy of existing controls already in place in Canadian law. The CCA will wait until all the details are available before commenting on the proposed changes and the manner in which the reported review panel will operate.

The Criminal Code already contains provisions that deal with pornography, child pornography, the promotion of hate, slander, libel, advocating crime and sundry other elements which have proved adequate in the past to deal with these offences.

Furthermore, the Supreme Court of Canada has issued rulings clarifying some of these activities such as pornography (Butler decision), child pornography (Robin Mitchell Sharp decision) , hate crimes (Zundel decision), etc. These decisions are steeped in rigorous research and prove how difficult it is to rush to judgment based on mere idiosyncratic and personal opinions.

The CCA is concerned that these “content tests” may be required by other funders of film and television productions, or for productions in other media, for example from publishers who produce controversial novels, poems or plays; from sound recording companies who produce music where lyrics are deemed objectionable, or other forms of artistic or cultural expression.

The CCA has asked the Minister of Canadian Heritage, the Hon. Josée Verner, and her officials to proceed with extreme caution and prudence in effecting revisions to the manner in which such decisions are made. The letter recalls that the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which guarantees freedom of expression, should be ardently and tirelessly defended by the Minister responsible for Canadian artistic and cultural expression.

The CCA will issue further commentary on this issue when the documentation is made available by the Department of Canadian Heritage.

The Canadian Conference of the Arts (CCA) is the national forum for the arts and cultural community in Canada. It provides research, analysis and consultations on public policies affecting the arts and the Canadian cultural institutions and industries. The CCA fosters informed public debate on policy issues and seeks to advance the cultural rights of Canadians.

- 30 -

Tags: ,

Related posts

Filed under : arts administration, movies
By Julianna Yau
On
At 3:13 pm
Comments : 0
Print This Post Print This Post

 
 
 

Copy Cats: Copyright and Appropriation in the Media Arts

With the people they have lined up for this panel, this will prove to be an interesting and heated discussion. What will be interesting is the specific focus on media arts (keeping in mind that all art forms work a just differently enough for it to be problematic to treat them all the same).

A panel including: Jonathan Culp, Johanna Householder, Jonathan Sommer and Laura Murray
Date: Sunday, April 6 at 2:30 pm
Location: at Trinity Square Video, 401 Richmond St. West, Suite 376
Co-presented by the Images Festival

Tags: , ,

Related posts

Filed under : art, copyright, movies
By Julianna Yau
On
At 10:40 am
Comments : 0
Print This Post Print This Post